Here’s a novel idea: ranking the 2022 college football teams based on what they’ve actually done rather than name recognition or recent glory.
Too often, every year, teams get the benefit of the doubt because of success in years past, sometimes even several years past. For instance, Clemson recently jumped Michigan football in the AP top 25 despite both teams having the same record and both having played basically the same game the Saturday before. Now, Clemson potentially could have been ranked higher than the Wolverines prior to that point thanks to two then-ranked wins, but it was only the week that it beat Boston College in the same fashion with a similar score to Michigan’s win over Indiana that the Tigers rose above the Wolverines.
Buy Wolverines Tickets
Fast forward a week, and former Alabama quarterback Greg McElroy is taking a different approach. As he says, he’s ranking teams based off of their resume. Michigan’s started light, for instance, but has been solid since. Thus, he has the Wolverines as a top team.
Here are his current top 10.
McElroy: “Not the greatest resume at this point, but not a resume they need to be embarrassed by.”
Alabama Crimson Tide
McElroy: “It’s simply about what you’ve accomplished. You’ve had a couple close calls, and then you got got last week in a way that was unfortunate. “
McElroy: “They have two solid wins against Power Five teams and then one very solid win against a very good Sun Belt team.”
Ole Miss Rebels
McElroy: “I am not thoroughly impressed with what Ole Miss has done so far. They have two good wins, one was against Kentucky, one was against Troy. “
McElroy: “Clemson – three really, really solid wins – a team to watch right now is Clemson – where they’re at and where they might be.”
TCU Horned Frogs
McElroy: “This team is grossly underrated in a lot of polls – they also have really good wins against both Kansas, who’s 5-1, and Oklahoma.
“They have three legit wins in my eyes.”
Ohio State Buckeyes
McElroy: “I think Ohio State is unbelivably good. They’re a juggernaut offensively. (…) Ohio State has played one team with a winning record. They’ve beaten one team with a winning record. And that team is not that great. That would be Toledo. Toledo is in the MAC. When your best win is against a MAC team, albeit a dominant win, I hold that against you. “
McElroy: “As of right now, Georgia is still with so much on the table.”
McElroy: “Tell me who has a better resume than this right now. (…) It’s the best win (Alabama) in college football right now. “
McElroy: “Michigan had one of the most convincing victories of the year against a team in Penn State that I think is OK. (…) The dominance that was on display from Michigan in start to finish in that game (…) that was really the first mega test for Michigan. (…) Michigan, right now, to me, is playing as well, if not better, than anyone in college football. “